Smart Home Hubs: Definitive Guide

by May 17, 2019Smart Hubs

What is a smart hub?

A smart home hub is a dedicated server that acts as a central point of communication between all smart devices, manages automation rules and gives a single interface to your smart home. If used correctly, it becomes a key component of the smart home and acts as the brain of the home automation ecosystem.

Having a smart home or not is a difference between treating smart devices like toys and being serious about making your home smart. This article will help you understand why and help you to choose the best hub for you.

What smart hubs do?

  1. Connect all smart devices together

There are thousands of smart home devices, but they are rarely well integrated with each other.  The benefit of linking them all is to have a foundation for any serious automations or managing them from a single place. That is exactly what smart hubs do.

The way hubs do it is by using communication protocols. You might already have a number of different devices using Z-wave, Zigbee, Bluetooth, RF or wifi. Having a powerful hub would allow to treat them as a single system with simplifying management and controls.

MORE: Is Zigbee really better than Z-wave

  1. Provide a single interface for your smart home

Another important aspect of a hub is the user interface that helps you to work with all the devices from one place and also easily interact with them. In addition, there are two more benefits:

  • Adoption of your smart home by the whole of your family. An intuitive user interface will allow you to make sure that all your family can use, control and manage your smart home.
  • No more useless apps: A single place to manage devices means that you do not need 3 different apps and web interfaces for your Philips Hue lights, Somfy blinds and sprinkler system.
  1. Manage routines to automate your smart home

Once you have all the smart devices that you want to control in a single system you can do the real magic with home automation. As an example, you can:

  • Set up a rule to switch off the air conditioning if the door or windows are open for a long time
  • Send a notification to your kids to turn off their TVs. The lights in each bedroom flash as a warning and 10 minutes later the TVs switch off automatically.
  • Notify you of specific events depending on whether you are at home or not
  • Flash the lights while you work in your garage when someone rings the doorbell

The opportunities are endless and only possible if you have all devices in a single system controlled by a capable smart home hub.

What are the main benefits of using a smart hub?

There are two main benefits of having a dedicated smart home hub:

  • Helps to build a complete smart home: As a homeowner, connecting several devices and controlling them individually can be tedious. But with a smart hub, the controlling and management is streamlined into a centralized platform: your smartphone app.
  • Saves time and effort: If you are only dealing with a few products like smart outlets or smart light bulbs, you can find a way to control them individually using your smartphone app. But what if you have a couple more devices from different manufacturers that require switching between apps, how easy is that going to be? Not only does it involve lots of effort up front, but you’ll also be wasting time and complicating your smart home experience.

Smart speakers like the Google Home or Amazon Echo aim to replace hubs. This is unlikely to happen mainly due to two reasons:

  • Voice assistants don’t offer full compatibility with standards and protocols (for example only Alexa provides the ability to integrate Zigbee devices)
  • They are not designed to manage automation routines which is the main component to unlock the smart home benefits

What are the disadvantages of smart hubs?

  • Additional costs: Smart hub is an additional piece of hardware which will roughly cost you from $70 (SmartThings) to $200 (HomeSeer). You can also have them for free (Home Assistant) if you already have a server or NAS. You may also need to buy additional hardware to communicate with some smart devices. Moreover, some hubs will require you to install the software on an always-on computer, which is something that may not be feasible.
  • The learning curve to start using smart home hubs to the maximum. If you are a beginner, be ready to learn a few terminologies as well as how to operate all the devices connected in the system. Fortunately, there are dozens of Youtube videos on most of the popular hubs so you should be able to get through them using the help of these videos in addition to the information available from the manufacturer.
  • Continuous maintenance: the journey does not end once you set up your hub. You will need to invest some time in updating it so it can be in good working condition. Manufacturers try to bring new functionality so constant upgrades will also require some attention.

Are Smart Hubs secure?

While consumers are buying more smart home devices, the actual security of these devices begs the question. This concern is magnified as hackers continue to exploit different methods of exploiting weaknesses in IoT devices.

Like any other network device, there is a security risk of unauthorized access with any smart home hub. In the case of the breach, documents and sensitive information could be lost with the financial and other crimes linked to that.

Governments across the world started realizing the potential dangers of security breaches in smart homes. As an example, the UK government is now exploring the use of mandatory security labels to educate customers on safety.

Security risks can be better managed if the following good practices are followed:

  • Security awareness by users: Strong passwords and not exposing devices to the internet will significantly reduce the risks
  • Manufacturers effort to design products with security features (SSL encryption, no plain text passwords)
  • Constant updates to the software used in the hubs applied to implement the latest fixes and enhancements

How to secure your smart hubs

Securing your smart hub is extremely important. We recommend the following key tips to secure your smart hub and make sure you are protected:

  • Use strong passwords: This guide will help you to create strong passwords and remember them well
  • Do not expose your hub to the internet: some hubs will allow you to expose all the controls of the hub to the internet. Please avoid this if possible
  • Only share access when needed: granting access to your hub to many people can lead to unauthorised access and security breaches. Please always create guest passwords and revoke access when not needed.
  • Monitor and control your hub: make sure you see who is using the hub and take note any suspicious usage
  • Change the passwords regularly: make sure you rotate the passwords and revoke access from users when not needed
  • Use local communication protocols: Zigbee and Z-wave are local protocols having very high standards of security. Where possible avoid using other less secure means to connect your smart home devices. While this isn’t 100% foolproof, it helps reduce the number of items that can be a target of the attackers.
  • Do not buy cheap untested devices: There are a number of very affordable home automation devices from unknown manufacturers (especially from some Asian countries not known for good IP and security management). Be careful in buying and using it in your smart home ecosystem as it can increase security risks.

Our Recommendation: Best smart hubs to buy

Manufacturers understand that a hub will open up the door to the growing smart home industry. As a result, a number of choices are available for the consumer.

Should you choose mass-market or open source smart hub?

First thing you need to decide when buying a smart home hub is a choice between are mass-market and DIY open-source smart hubs. Both have pros and cons.

  • Mass-market hubs like SmartThings and Wink aim to have a simple and easy to use interface with well-designed mobile apps to make sure that users regardless of technical proficiency will be able to use the hub. The downside is that those products sometimes do not allow the flexibility and complexity to truly unlock the benefits of smart home devices.
  • Open-source hubs like Home Assistant and OpenHAB is mainly community driven open-source projects that have a very good pace of development and sophistication of features unavailable in mass market hubs. The downside is that there is no official support and varied quality of software releases (sometimes resulting in errors).

To give you a recommendation on the best hub to buy, we researched and tested 9 main mass market and open source hubs. We looked at both the technical and user aspect to give you our opinion on the top hubs for your smart home. Our main criteria were:

  • High-security standards and up to date patches
  • Good connectedness and integrations
  • Overall stability
  • UI user-friendliness
  • Development potential and future proofing

Based on the below, see our recommendations for the best hubs to buy:

  • Best for the majority users – (Samsung SmartThings v3): This hub has the best balance between ease of use and functionality. It has great UI to make sure that even inexperienced users would be able to use it. In addition, it covers all the major communication protocols (Zigbee and Z-wave) and has many well-developed integrations with the majority of the smart devices in the market. See a detailed review.
  • Best for advanced users – Home Assistant: If you are keen to invest a bit more time in configuring your smart home, there is no better option than Home Assistant. It has the most modern architecture, UI and very active community. Your invested time will be paid off by having complex automation routines that make the most of your smart home. See a detailed review.
  • Best of both – Hubitat Elevation: Hubitat, the newest hubs in our review tries to combine the advantages of both options above. It has better support than Home Assistant while maintaining the flexibility and the granularity of controls.  It also excels SmartThings in some UI options (although they take time to learn) while avoids the cloud issues by having a fast and secure local processing. See detailed review.

Overview of smart hub:

HubOur Opinion

SmartThings v3
SmartThings v3 $67.01 on Amazon

  • Further improves v2 allowing wireless Ethernet connection, thus simplifying the installation process.
  • A large number of smart devices are support
  • Overreliance on the cloud which had a number of recent outages
  • A mobile app is not very well organized

Home Assistant

Best Hardware for Home Assistant
  • Beautiful UI
  • A lot of native integrations
  • Can work with almost any protocol (additional hardware)
  • Can run on NAS or home server
  • Truly local
  • Secure
  • No dedicated hardware that makes it difficult to start
  • Still requires technical knowledge (but worth it)
  • Some stability issues

Hubitat Elevation
Best smart hub for advanced users $99.95 on Amazon

  • Great third-party development support
  • No reliance on cloud services
  • Truly local processing and very fast
  • Limited devices integration support
  • UI is a bit too complex
  • No mobile app
  • New device with community and support being built

Vera Plus
Vera Plus hub $99.95 on Amazon

  • Best technical support compared to other hubs
  • Good value for money
  • Doesn't rely on the cloud like the SmartThing smart hubs
  • No good documentation
  • Plugins are of poor quality
  • Not as responsive
  • No Zigbee Support

SmartThings v2
SmartThings v2 $87.89 on Amazon

  • Well tested product with a very good community of users and developed platform
  • No monthly fee (unlike HomeTroller Zee S2)
  • Multiple wireless protocol support
  • Comes with clear and easy UI and documentation
  • Overreliance on the cloud which had a number of recent outages
  • Mobile app is not very well organized

HomeSeer HomeTroller Zee S2
HomeSeer HomeTroller Zee S2 $199.95 on Amazon

  • Well designed UI to control and configure devices
  • Supports multiple protocols so it's easy to integrate all your smart devices
  • Expensive
  • Low-end version has many limitations (only 5 plugins)
  • Monthly subscriptions

Domoticz

  • Open source and free
  • Great at creating complex and complicated scenes
  • Highly customizable
  • No dedicated support

Wink Hub 2

  • Supports all popular smart home protocols
  • Setup is streamlined and simple, as is adding new devices
  • Irritating ads in the app
  • Learning curve
  • Had availability issues recently

1. SmartThings v3: New top-pick for the majority users

The SmartThings v3 is the next iteration of a very popular SmartThings hub. It brings wireless connection but removing battery backup to already very popular mass market smart home hub. SmartThings continue to provide a great eco-system of a wide range of smart products as well as developed community and integrations. It supports and can control devices from more than 40 brands, including cameras, speakers, lights, voice assistants, switches, sensors, and a lot more.

WHAT WE LIKED:

  • Now with a wireless connection to the router
  • More automation
  • Compatible with Zigbee/Z-Wave

WHAT WE DID NOT LIKE:

  • Absence of Nest integration
  • Difficulty in upgrading

The strengths of SmartThings is community and mature platform that includes add-ons, integrations and

There are a few categories that may be of interest to you and most likely fall into these groups:

  • Light and switches. It connects with lights and switches from GE, Leviton, Cree, Philips Hue, Sylvania, LIFX, and control them by changing the brightness, turning them off/on at a specified time, etc.
  • Doorbells and cameras. It works with brands like Ring, Samsung, Skybell, Arlo, etc., and you can set up video notifications, mobile device alerts, and more.
  • Door locks. It supports door locks from Kwikset, Yale, Schlage, etc., which helps you lock and unlock your smart home automatically as you in and out of the home.
  • Thermostats. You can connect devices from different brands including Ecobee, Honeywell, etc.

Credit: https://diysmarthomeguide.com

Installation and Use

The first step in setting up your smart home is to place the hub in a central location. Make sure it’s not on top of or immediately next to other wireless devices. Then, using the micro-USB power cable/power adapter, connect the SmartThings hub to a power source and power it up.

You’ll also need to download the SmartThings mobile app, which can be found in either the Google Play Store or the Apple iOS App Store. Once downloaded, create your Samsung Account and set your location. Then from the dashboard, then tap add device. Select the hub and follow the on-screen guide to connect it. You’ll use your phone’s camera to scan the QR code on the back of the hub.

Now, you’re ready to connect your devices. When setting up the SmartThing hub, make sure the device you’re connecting is within 15 feet of the hub.

You can connect one of Yale/Kwikset/Schlage smart locks or Netgear Arlo cameras, or Ecobee thermostats, or Lutron switches, or Ring video doorbells, or Philips Hue smart lights, and a few other brands. You can find the list of all the supported devices here. And if you want, you can add Google Assistant or Amazon Alexa for voice control commands for your connected devices.

In terms of usability, the newest version of the SmartThings hub is quite easy and offers more simplicity than previous versions, especially during the setup.

Automation rules in Smart Things

Automation rules are all about creating scenarios to help make your life easier. They are customized settings that you have in place to respond to certain triggers. For example, you could have a scene titled “back from work” where the thermostat lower the temperature, the front door opens and the living room light turns on, all of which are executed simultaneously when you step into your home.

You can even teach your smart home some new tricks by setting up scenes, which are routines that control more than one device at a time. Select the devices tab and add your scene with a title – could be something like “Sleeping time”. Now add the smart devices you want to control, for instance, lights, thermostat, locks, etc. You could then configure the light to turn off, the temperature to be adjusted and the door locked when you go to bed at night.

SmartThings Mobile App

Before you can use the hub with your smartphone, you need to download the app that’s suitable for your phone’s operating system. The iOS app is a bit different from that of the Android, in that it’s simpler, lighter, and with fewer features.

Once you have the app, open it and search for your device, then add it. Some devices such as thermostat, TV, etc., might be auto-synced but the hub itself might not, so you may have to search for and manually add it to your mobile phone.

Comparisons

  • SmartThings vs Hubitat: The Hubitat hub is similar in terms of the functionality and features. However, it’s more advanced than the SmartThings v3 and doesn’t require an internet connection to operate it.
  • SmartThings v3 vs SmartThings v2: If you already have the version 2 of this hub, you may not want to upgrade as there isn’t much difference between the two. Version 3 only comes with a few improvements, mainly connecting through wireless when setting up.
  • SmartThings v3 vs Home Assistant. The best thing about SmartThings v3 is that it became even better than v2 with the same great community and support. For the majority users, it is the best smart home. At the same time, if you ready to invest some time in learning new skills, keen to tinker and like to have complexity and flexibility, Home Assistant is the best option to go for.

MORE: SmartThings vs Home Assistant

  • SmartThings v3 vs HomeSeer: If you are a beginner, then the SmartThings is your choice but if you are experienced and want more sophistication, then the HomeSeer might offer more customization.
  • SmartThings v3 vs VeraPlus: The VeraPlus has radios for all major home automation standards, which is similar to what you get on the SmartThings v3. However, it doesn’t support Bluetooth and Zigbee just yet, which somehow limits the number of non-Z-Wave devices you can use with it.
  • SmartThings v3 vs Domoticz: It should be noted that this is an open source software and the hardware doesn’t come with it. However, you’ll need your Z-Wave, Zigbee, etc., supported hardware such as motion sensors, locks, lights, etc. Also, it’s less expensive and great for people who want that extra freedom.

2. Hubitat Elevation: The best smart hub for advanced users

Hubitat is a relatively new kid on the block. It tries to bridge the gap between the commercial mass market products like SmartThings and Wink and more advanced open-source solution like Home Assistant and OpenHAB.

Our summary of the device is that it offers good UI and interesting way of configuring and using your smart home eco-system. We also like the fact that it tries to have all the controls locally, without the reliance on the cloud. Saying that we still recommend SmartThings if you want a mature and simple solution to manage your smart devices. On the other spectrum of a hub, for more tech-savvy users we would recommend Home Assistant for a more innovative approach to development and pace of new functionality appearing. We also like the progress on the UI and number of integrations that if offers.

WHAT WE LIKED:

  • Local processing
  • Z-Wave and Zigbee compatible
  • Locally stored smart home logic
  • Excellent management of devices
  • Complex interactions among devices

WHAT WE DID NOT LIKE:

  • No remote access
  • Steep learning curve
  • Limited device support
  • Absence of a mobile app

Credit: https://hubitat.com/

What hardware does Hubitat Elevation support?

The Hubitat Elevation is compatible with Alexa, Google Assistant, Zigbee, Z-Wave, Lutron, LAN, and cloud-connected devices. This means you have a wide range of smart devices you can connect to your Hubitat hub, just like the other commercial hubs on the market.

In terms of natively integrating devices, it has limited device support compared to more mature hubs like SmartThings. For example, it does support the Amazon Echo, but not Google Home (at least not fully) and IFTTT but not Stringify.

One thing that’s good about it, however, is that the range of supported devices is growing fast. Having said that, the Hubitat Elevation supports Z-Wave, Zigbee, Lutron, and even Philips Hue Native. So, if you are big on lighting, you have your base covered here. And when you add excellent support for things like locks, cameras, smoke detector, then these are enough for a decent home automation setup.

Installation and use

As with many other hubs, the first thing you want to do is register the hub, after which you’ll be directed to the home screen. You’ll see the App, Devices, and Settings menus on the left side and the Drivers Code, Logs, System Events, and App Code on the lower end.

Most of your configuration will be done on the Apps menu and it’s where you’ll pair your devices to the hub as well as group devices as well as setting up rules like turning on living room light when the front door is opened.

To connect your smart devices, you need to activate Apps like Nest integration, Rule Machine, Sonos integration, and others. It’s also at this stage you can add either Google Home or Alexa. Only after you’ve integrated these services will you be able to add your devices, which shouldn’t take more than a few minutes.

When it comes to working through the hub and configuring devices, the native app makes it easy. It’s actually one of fun as you can do a lot of complicated things with it, aside from controlling your thermostats, sensors, locks, speakers, lights, and others. You can connect more than 100 unique smart devices and as you update it, you get additional support for even more devices.

Creating automation rules in Hubitat

The Hubitat allows you to create complex scenarios for controlling all your smart devices. This is one of the strong points for this hub and where it has an edge over others like the Samsung SmartThings. For example, you can create rules to trigger some devices as soon as some situations are met. You could set the light to dim at a certain period of the day or you could set the thermostat to adjust to a certain temperature as the weather becomes hot.

Hubitat does not have a mobile app (intestinally)

The Hubitat Elevation does not come with any mobile app. Instead, a web app is available for controlling your smart home devices. You’ll need to create this from the Dashboard Manager, which is available to you after registering your device online. As of this writing, a mobile dedicated app is in the works and hopefully may come with the next version of the device.

How does Hubitat stack up compared to other hubs:

  • Hubitat Vs Samsung SmartThings: SmartThings is a mass-market product which has a bit more polished, but simpler and more limited functionality. You get the ecosystem and third party support which is similar to what the Hubitat hub is trying to offer but has a much higher number of integrated devices. The downside to the SmartThings hub is availability. Since the device is heavily reliant on the cloud service there should be great uptime, but there is enough downtime to make it not worth it. This interruption or lost time affects how the hub works and often affects the control of devices.

MORE: Home Assistant Vs SmartThings

  • Hubitat vs Home Assistant: Although we are big fans of Home Assistant, we really liked the fact that Hubitat tries to bridge the gap to mass market solutions. It feels more flexible and manages well the complex automation rules that needed for a good smart home setup. Saying that we would still go for Home Assistant as it feels you would need the same amount of time to get really comfortable with both system, but Home Assistant pace of development, community, and integration makes it really shine compared to Hubitat.

MORE: Home Assistant Vs OpenHAB

  • Hubitat vs Vera: The Hubitat is similar to the Vera in that both are backed by excellent customer support. In terms of performance, however, the Hubitat is far better. If you are looking at in terms of performance, third-party support and stability, the Hubitat is the better option.
  • Hubitat vs HomeSeer: Both hubs are designed for advanced users. However, HomeSeer hubs are more expensive. So, Hubitat is a good option when comparing it with HomeSeer.
  • Hubitat vs OpenHAB: It is difficult to compare Hubitat with OpenHAB – even if both are open source, they are very different. OpenHAB is incredibly stable and very well thought through the system with interesting solutions on UI and device management. At the same time, it is outdated and does not have much development energy behind.
  • Hubitat vs Domoticz: Of course, this hub isn’t as much adopted as the more commercial versions. This means there might not be dedicated support as much as you can get from Hubitat.

3. Home Assistant: The most powerful and the best for DIY

We are big fans of home Assistant. It recently had 5 years anniversary and had a great vision laid out for the future. You can read it here.  It tries to create a secure, local and convenient tool to manage your smart home eco-system and so far we were very impressed by the attempts.

There are many reasons why we think that Home Assistant is the best open source smart home hub are:

  • A fresh, modern and easily customizable web interface
  • Easy integration with over 1,300 smart devices
  • Hass.io which is a user-friendly version with one-click management of updates and backup
  • Easy add-on management (Pi-hole, MotionEye etc.)
  • Ability to easily configure and manage advanced configuration especially

Home Assistant UI example: Credit; saggiamente.com

At the same time, we are aware of some issues. Its rapid development brings new features quickly, but also means occasional bugs and frustrating experience for users. You also will need to pay $5 for easy integration with Google Home / Alexa (there is a free manual way as well).

You can install Home Assistant in many ways. For the majority users Hass.io which is the self-contained flavour of Home Assistant (and basically a docker supervisor). It will take the management of updates, back up and also ability to add very good library of add-ons. You can install it on Raspberry Pi, any other NAS and Home Server (using Docker)

We have a very extensive comparison of Home Assistant Vs OpenHAB, which will give you more technical details. The article also gives examples of UI, automation rules and some concern we have over the product.

Please also consider looking at a couple of related articles:

4. Vera Plus: Good all-around option

WHAT WE LIKED:

  • Supports for Z-Wave devices
  • Enhanced functionality
  • Supports multiple protocols
  • Excellent technical support
  • No reliance on cloud services
  • Good value for money

WHAT WE DID NOT LIKE:

  • Poor UI
  • Bad documentation
  • Outdated plugins

What hardware Vera Plus supports?

Vera Plus has Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, ZigBee, and Z-Wave compatibility. Compared to others like the HomeSeer hub, there are no monthly fees involved to enjoy the hub to its fullest potential. It also supports devices from popular brands like Sonos, Samsung, Honeywell, Kwikset, Nest, Philips and much more, which makes it possible to mix and match brands for great smart home experience.

The Vera Plus supports up to 1500 Z-Wave compatible devices, which means you can integrate your cameras, lamps, sensors, locks and a lot more to transform your home into a truly automated and smart home. When everything works properly, you get a hands-free experience that smart hubs are designed to bring.

Credit: https://www.reichelt.com

Vera Plus Installation

The setup process isn’t complicated; all you have to do is follow the instructions in the Quick Start Guide that comes with your package. First, you need to connect it to your router, using the supplied RJ45 Ethernet cable after which you power it up. Once it’s on, you’ll need to go to https://home.getvera.com to register your device with the manufacturer.

After your registration, you’ll be redirected to the Dashboard where you’ll be able to complete your setup. On the dashboard, you’ll be able to add devices to your network, which is mostly done through a setup wizard.

Mobile App

Vera hubs come with perfectly working mobile apps and this is the case with the Vera Plus too. The app allows you to monitor and control your smart home devices from your palm, even when you’re not at home.

Comparisons  

  • Vera Plus vs SmartThings. If you’ve used the Smart Things v2 hub before, you’ll know that it depends entirely on cloud access and will be almost unusable without an internet connection. The VeraPlus on the other hand, like the Hubitat, doesn’t need access to the cloud to work.
  • Vera Plus vs Hubitat. If you are looking for a great alternative to the VeraPlus, then consider the Hubitat hub. In terms of price, they are similar and offer more or less the same functionality.
  • Vera Plus vs Domoticz. The Domoticz is an open source software that offers good features if you don’t want to use a commercial hub. While Vera Plus may be practical for beginners, the Domoticz requires technical shrewdness.
  • Vera Plus vs HomeSeer. HomeSeer offers three levels of commercial hubs, with price starting from the low hundreds to thousands of dollars. The level of technicality required for operating HomeSeer hub is also higher compared to that of the Vera Plus.

5. SmartThings v2: Still good for the majority of the users

WHAT WE LIKED:

  • Multiple wireless protocols
  • Easy to install
  • Clear user instructions
  • No monthly usage fee

WHAT WE DID NOT LIKE:

  • Depends on cloud access
  • App looks disorganized

Smartthings is the first commercial mass market product that is still very popular and has a great community behind.

What hardware SmartThings v2 supports?

Not only does it support Z-Wave, but it also supports Zigbee, Wi-Fi. And although there are some local commands that can be processed by the hardware CPU, the SmartThings hub v2 is actually cloud-reliant. So, you can’t really do much when your internet connection is down.

It supports a wide spectrum of third-party products including Philips Hue, LIFX, Ecobee, Honeywell thermostat, Leviton lighting, Yale door locks, and a lot more. Adding third-party integrations is very easy too.

Credit: https://smarthomesolver.com/

Installation

It’s fast and easy to set up. First, you need to download the application and register an account. After that, you’ll need to follow the installation instructions, which is pretty straightforward. You need to install AA batteries for the battery backup, connect it to your router, and power it up. Unlike the SmartThings hub v3 or Wink hub, you can’t connect to your router wirelessly, so you have to use a wired Ethernet connection.

After you are done with that, you can have it scan for compatible devices or just select from the provided list of devices on the unit. The SmartThings hub shouldn’t have problems detecting your smart home devices, which gives it a slight edge over Hubitat and a few other hubs that require manually adding devices.

Mobile App

There are mobile apps for iOS, Windows, and Android devices, which is friendly and better compared to previous versions. You’ll be able to get in-app help or online assistance along with video and a step by step guide to resolve problems.

The Smart Home Monitor page is also available on the app, so you can see the overview of your home at a glance. And this is where you’ll have access to different menus to configure alerts and devices.

Comparison

  • SmartThings v2 vs SmartThings v3. In v2, you can only connect to your router using a wired Ethernet connection. The newest model, SmartThings v3, offers the option to connect to your router through Wi-Fi, giving you additional flexibility and one of the greatest advantages of the newest model over the v2.
  • SmartThings v2 vs Hubitat Elevation. If you don’t plan to use your hub with a broadband connection, you should definitely check out the Hubitat Elevation which is the most suitable model for those who want their automation system operate locally most of the time.
  • SmartThings v2 vs Vera Plus. While Vera Plus offers lots of plugins you can install from the web interface, most of them are quite outdated, broken or incompatible. If you have a thick skin and don’t mind finding the way through trial and error, then go for the Vera Plus. But if you don’t want to fiddle with your hub to get the best out of it, then the SmartThings v2 is still better.
  • SmartThings v2 vs Domoticz. A good option for those who want open source software to manage their smart home setup. Moreover, Domoticz provides a platform for creating complex rules and IFTTT recipes.
  • SmartThings v2 vs Home Assistant. It is difficult to compare those two – they are from different worlds. For the majority of users who do not want to invest in learning how to manage a new device SmartThings would be a better choice. For all the rest who want to have complexity and flexibility, Home Assistant is the best smart home hub there is.

MORE: SmartThings vs Home Assistant

  • SmartThings v2 vs HomeSeer. The HomeTroller Zee S2 is a more advanced hub than the SmartThings v2. So deciding which one to go for is dependent on your experience as a user.

6. HomeSeer HomeTroller Zee S2: Expensive but great support

HomeSeer is another option for smart home hubs (controllers as HomeSeer calls them). The difference from other hubs is that the brand is the US focused, has the whole eco-system of devices and provides excellent customer support. On the other side, it is the most expensive option out of all other hubs we reviewed with the least expensive version comes at $99 plus over $100 for software.

WHAT WE LIKED:

  • Customizable with HSTouch Designer
  • Features IFTTT channel
  • Amazon Echo voice integration
  • Comes with iOS/Android app
  • Intuitive programming rules
  • Efficient Z-Wave integration
  • Supports multiple protocols

WHAT WE DID NOT LIKE:

  • Very expensive
  • No Zigbee support
  • Controller limited to 5 plugins
  • Individual purchase of automation products

There are currently 5 models on the market from HomeSeer and the cheapest of them is the HomeTroller Zee S2. Most of their devices are aimed at the high-end of the market segment in terms of the technicality involved as well as the price. Compared to other brands like SmartThings, Vera, Hubitat, the HomeTroller Zee S2 is not a consumer-focused product because it requires some know-how to set up.

There are other models from HomeSeer, other than the HomeTroller Zee S2, which is the smallest of them with some limitation in the number of automation technologies you can connect at a time. At the time of writing this guide, it’s only five (for example, can be restricted to only Alexa, Nest, IFTTT, Zigbee, and Z-Wave devices).

Credit: Z-wave.com

The HomeTroller hub supports Z-Wave, Zigbee, Insteon, X10, UPB, A10, which means you can integrate a wide number of home automation products.

Integration to devices

There are different models/version of the HomeSeer controllers with different levels of device and service compatibility. There are expensive models that support an unlimited number of devices as well as cheaper models that only support 5 drivers/plugins such as the HomeTroller Zee S2.

The drivers, while they are free to download, come in both premium and free versions.

Installation

Although those who want to use the device needs to have some sort of technical ability in setting up smart home devices, there is a thriving online community with constant webinars and tutorials that can help in the installation and use of the device. But still, you may want to look at the other models out there if you don’t have the capacity to set up a system like this.

Mobile App

The HSTouch app is available for Android and iOS so you can control and manage your automation devices and program from your mobile device. It’s possible that you may not be tech-savvy, in which case it may not be suitable for you as the HomeSeer software is more technical than that of others. So, if you are not familiar with what terms like firmware, drivers, plugins, etc., deals with, then this isn’t for you.

Comparison

  • HomeSeer Vs Vera Plus. Compared to the HomeSeer hub, VeraPlus interface is quite buggy and slow. The code is poor and it isn’t properly documented, which can greatly impact the user experience in a negative way.
  • HomeSeer vs SmartThings. The HomeSeer hub is a bit more advanced than the SmartThings v3 hub, which means it’s not suitable for beginners. If you like the functions in the HomeSeer hub but don’t have the technical expertise, you can look at the Samsung hub.
  • HomeSeer vs Vs Hubitat. If you are put off with the price of the HomeTroller Zee S2, the SmartThings is a close alternative that offers quite the same level of complexity in terms of creating automation rules.
  • HomeSeer vs Vs Home Assistant. The only two reasons why we would prefer HomeSeer devices over Home Assistant is the customer service and more user-friendliness. Otherwise Home Assistant all the way.
  • HomeSeer vs Vs Domoticz. As you probably already know, the Domoticz is open source and offers the same complexity you’ll find in a HomeSeer hub plus the affordability.

7. Domoticz: Tested and free

WHAT WE LIKED:

  • It is free
  • Suitable for advanced users
  • Easy installation procedure
  • A broad range of supported devices
  • Highly customizable

WHAT WE DID NOT LIKE:

  • Not actively developed as other open source solutions
  • No dedicated support team
  • Open to more attack/hacking

Like the other commercial hubs, Domoticz supports Bluetooth, Infrared, Zigbee, Z-Wave and a few more protocols. This makes it easier to integrate a variety of smart home devices. Moreover, in terms of the number of devices you can integrate with this system, you don’t have any restriction like the HomeSeer hubs and those hubs that don’t support other protocols outside of Z-Wave like the Wink hub.

As stated before, Domoticz supports a host of protocols like Z-Wave, etc., as well as standards like Bluetooth, HomeKit, etc. It supports encryption too so that others don’t listen on your devices. It also connects to services over the internet, with the advantage being that you can store and retrieve data from the cloud, such as the current weather for example.

Integration of devices

It can connect to Z-Wave devices such as the Z-Wave controller, network cameras like the D-Link, as well as others including HIKvision, Foscam, and Nexus. It also works with Bluetooth, Zigbee, Wi-Fi light, Logitech remote, Philips Hue and other lights too. There is an abundance of hardware you can add to the system and that is entirely dependent on your tastes. Moreover, it costs less than other hubs like SmartThings, HomeSeer, etc., since you only have to buy only the hardware that you need.

Installation

Aside from macOS and Windows, Domoticz supports Linux, FreeNAS, Raspberry Pi (Ubuntu), and Synology NAS. To install, you first need to download the current version that’s compatible with your operating system.

Once installed, click open and you will be guided through the installation by a setup wizard. Just follow each prompt and you’ll be able to install it without glitches. After installing it, you’ll have access to a local Dashboard where you can view the status and monitor all of your smart devices. Also, this is where you’ll be able to add and configure all your devices including switches, lights, sensors, weather, thermostat, smoke detector, and a lot more. You can also set up alerts for mobile notifications, which can be very handy when you’re away from home.

Mobile App

There is a mobile app for Android and iOS to make controlling your smart devices easy. From the app’s interface, you can manage your cameras, utilities, switches, lights, and a lot more using your iPhone or Android device. You can also carry out activities such as checking out historical data in graphs and logs as well as controlling all your devices within the app. The Android app is available from GitHub and Google Play Store with updates and features added regularly. If you are an iPhone user, you can get the app from the Apple Store with the same level of functionality.

Comparisons

  • Domitcz vs Vera. Vera is built with poor documentation to support it. While it allows you to write your own code in LUA programing language, the documentation to help you along the way is scanty.
  • Domitcz vs SmartThings. SmartThings is designed for beginners and average users while Domoticz is for IT professionals or those with technical ability. In terms of price, SmartThings is more expensive and the level of satisfaction of support from the manufacturer is ebbing in recent years.
  • Domitcz vs Hubitat. Just like Hubitat, Domoticz equally requires a learning curve. Both are not beginner-friendly, although they can be learned and mastered for anyone willing. In terms of functionality, the Hubitat hub is more advanced and comes with lots of features that draw more people towards it.
  • Domitcz vs HomeSeer. In terms of the technicality required in operating both systems, the HomeSeer hubs and Domoticz are quite similar. HomeSeer is more expensive in the price department and has a few different models at different price points.

8. Wink Hub 2: Expensive but great support

While some speculate that the dedicated smart home hub is largely dying in favour of devices like the Amazon Echo and Google Home, there’s still a good use for dedicated hubs and their accompanying apps. One of the most loved smart home hubs is the wink hub, which is currently on its second generation. The wink hub is known for offering a tone of connectivity and is compatible with a range of standards including Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, Z-Wave, Zigbee, Lutron Clear Connect, etc.

Sadly, Wink was not available in shops for a while with many review sites and Reddit users withdrawing their support for the wink products.

Voice Assistants

1. Amazon Echo

Years after its birth, the device that inspired dozens of copycat smart speakers and thousands of replicas, the Amazon Echo 2nd generation is what’s on most people’s radar. This Amazon’s new Echo is smaller, cheaper, and promises better sound than before. But with all the competition today and even more in the pipeline, the 2nd generation Echo needs to prove its worth the money.

2. Google Home

The Google Home voice-activated speaker is Google’s way of competing with the Amazon Echo. And it’s impossible to talk about Google Home without also talking about Amazon’s Echo. They are very similar and both are voice-activated, connected smart speakers. You can add things to your to-do list or your shopping list and do a bunch of web searches, all with just your voice now. Google has further ambitions for the home that goes beyond what Amazon is currently doing, but let’s start with the device itself.

3. Home Kit

Apple’s HomeKit is another voice assistance that’s a bit different from Nest and Hive and offers relatively more features than the Google Home or Amazon Echo for Apple lovers. Unlike the Home or Echo, you aren’t buying any hardware or physical product, all of HomeKit platform is based on software on your iPhone. The software is your key to ruling over all your smart home devices.